Pinoy Marino Rights

by Atty. Dennis Gorecho

Spinal conditions  as compensable work-related illnesses

A seafarer’s spinal illness  is considered  compensable  due   to  strenuous  activities on board the vessel that could have led to or at least aggravated his work-related  medical conditions.

The Supreme Court used this rationale in  granting  total permanent disability in the case of Resty Caampued  vs. Next Wave Maritime Mgt.., Inc. (G.R. No. 253756 May 12, 2021)

 The seafarer was tasked to assist in the repair of the ship’s generator. He was directed to pull the lining of the generator’s piston. In a squatting position, he forcefully pulled the piston lining upward. Shortly thereafter, he suffered persistent mild pain on his lower back that later led to his   medical repatriation.

Upon his arrival in the country, he was diagnosed  to have suffered from at least three (3) spinal conditions, i.e., degenerative disc, spondylolisthesis, and spinal tuberculosis.Degenerative  disc disease is a spinal condition caused by the breakdown of the intervertebral discs which results in the loss of flexibility  and  ability  to  cushion  the spine. When discs degenerate, the vertebral bodies become closer together and this increased bone on bone friction causes the wearing a way of protective cartilage and results in  the  condition  known  as  osteoarthritis. The degenerating discs place excessive  stress  on  the joints  of the  spine and the  supporting  ligaments,  which,  overtime,  can  lead to the  formation of osteoarthritis.
Osteoarthritis is a stage of degenerative disc disease.

Spondylosis, on the other hand, is a term used to describe osteoarthritis of the spine.

The company denied the claims for disability benefits on the ground of non-work relatedness of spinal tuberculosis.

The Supreme Court ruled otherwise noting that the other illness, spinal disc degeneration/desiccation or osteoarthritis,  is a compensable disease.

Prior to assuming his duties as Engine Fitter aboard the principal’s vessel, the seafarer  was declared fit to work after  the Pre-Employment Examination (PEME) with the company-designated physician.  The seafarer showed no signs of any spinal injury before he boarded the vessel. 
His back  pain  and limited lumbar movement started only after he forcefully pulled the piston lining of the ship’s generator. And these symptoms persisted way beyond the time he got medically repatriated.

It is reasonable to claim a causal relationship between seafarer’s illness and  his  work  as Engine  Fitter  of  his employer’s   vessel.

Under Section 32-A (21) of the 2010 POEA-SEC, osteoarthritis is expressly considered as an occupational disease when contracted in any occupation involving any of the following: (a) joint strain from carrying heavy loads, or unduly heavy physical labor; (b) minor or major injuries to the joint; (c) excessive use or constant strenuous usage of a particular joint, (c) extreme temperature  changes  (humidity,  heat and cold  exposures);  and (d) faulty work posture or use of vibratory tools.

As Engine Fitter, the seafarer  was constantly exposed to strenuous work.

His responsibilities included several strenuous physical activities such as: (a) fabrication and shaping of steel, aluminum and other materials; (b) lifting of metals  and materials for fabrication; (c) setting up and operating manually controlled machines in skilled precision; (d) carrying and lifting heavy-duty tools and equipment during maintenance and repair; and (e) other all around strenuous duties as instructed  by  supervisor.

To carry out these duties, he had to stand for most of the day and constantly moved around.

Such strenuous activities could have led to or at least aggravated his condition, thus making it a compensable work-related illness.   

Moreover, despite the findings that the seafarer  has degenerative disc and spondylolisthesis,  the company only treated and based their findings of non-compensability on  the seafarer’s spinal tuberculosis.

The company  simply ignored the seafarer’s  pleas to  get him treated and medically assessed for his degenerative disc and spondylolisthesis, thus  remained untreated and unresolved.  Consequently,  no medical assessment and certificate were issued to him for these conditions.Without a valid final and definitive assessment from the company-designated doctors within the mandatory  120/240-day period, the law already steps in to consider a seafarer’s disability as total and permanent.
(Atty,  Dennis R. Gorecho heads the seafarers’ division of the Sapalo Velez Bundang Bulilan law offices. For comments, email info@sapalovelez.com, or call 09175025808 or 09088665786).