CARTOON BY: AARON PAUL C.CARIL

EDITORIAL

Bicam, Bring Your Receipts

The bicameral conference committee is back in season, and so is the annual guessing game: what will be in the national budget by the time the doors close? This year the stakes are higher. On October 20, the Supreme Court declared the 2024 and 2025 General Appropriations Acts unconstitutional insofar as Congress inflated the spending ceiling the President recommended. It also struck down key provisions on unprogrammed funds in the 2026 budget. Anyone sitting at the bicam table now does so with a judicial chaperone.

Consider what the Court actually voided. Congress raised unprogrammed appropriations in the 2024 budget by P449.5 billion, and the Special Road Fund in the 2025 budget by P17.99 billion. Special Provisions 1(a) and (b) on the release of unprogrammed funds in the 2026 budget fell as well. The Court found grave abuse of discretion: lawmakers may cut the President’s proposal, but they may not pad it. Unprogrammed funds themselves survive, but only as narrow, contingent items with no lump sums, clear priorities and real safeguards.

The Court also trained its eye on the bicam itself. Lump-sum appropriations that name only an amount, and leave the choice of projects to the executive after the budget is signed, were ruled out. Proceedings that revisit points both chambers had already settled, or slip in new items, must be transparent and documented. For years the committee did its work behind closed doors, and the public learned what was inside only after the ink dried. The era of mystery meat is over, or at least it is supposed to be.

That brings us to the 2027 budget, a P7.2-trillion proposal now headed for Senate plenary debates and, eventually, the bicam. The Budget Secretary says the offending SAGIP items are gone and that unprogrammed funds are the lowest since 2019. Yet House opposition members point to lump-sum items such as the P50-billion AFP modernization fund and the P42-billion financial assistance to local governments. Senator JV Ejercito has also flagged about P206 billion in realignments, along with cuts to the Metro Manila Subway and the North-South Commuter Railway, even as flood control gained another P8 billion.

Recalling the House bill is not the answer. Senate leaders warn, with reason, that it would eat a calendar already squeezed, and a reenacted budget is a worse outcome for everyone. But “we’ll fix it in the bicam” is exactly the sentence that gave the bicam its reputation. If corrections are needed, make them in the Senate version, in the open, line by line, so the conference committee has only real differences to reconcile and no surprises to deliver.

So here is our budget watch list. Watch for any total that exceeds the President’s recommendation. Watch for unprogrammed funds with vague triggers, and for lump sums wearing new names. Watch for last-minute insertions that appear in neither chamber’s version. And watch the livestream, because transparency is now a legal expectation, not a favor. The Court has handed Congress the rulebook. The public will be keeping score, and the receipts will be on camera.